Facebook has done more harm than good. I joined it back in 2004 when there was no wall, tagged photos or the myriad of applications on everything ridiculous.
Facebook has since gotten senselessly competitive and largely meaningless in achieving real communications.
According to Mark Zuckerberg, Facebook is “a social utility that helps people communicate more efficiently with their friends, families and coworkers.”
Let’s break this down.
(1) Friends: Of the handful of friends I don’t see but communicate on a periodic basis, we never depend on Facebook to catch up. I prefer a long chat over the phone or a trip to see each other any day.
The vast majority of my friends on facebook, however, are people I don’t care about. I don’t care the girl I went to camp with is now engaged. I don’t care my Asian American Association acquittance broke up with her boyfriend. I don’t want to know some guy I liked is still dating that girl. I don’t care the girl who used to live down the hall from me is in Europe with her sorority sisters. And then there are the handful of people whose pictures make me wonder, “do I know you?”
What does it mean to say we have 1000 or 2000 friends, when those connections does not get me anywhere – because being able to friend someone on facebook, being able to follow someone’s life consistently for years over sheer boredom do not equal to real connections that produce real benefits. It’s a big waste of my time.
(2) Family: God forbid my parents join facebook. God forbid that, along with any aunts, uncles, or grandmothers. I am friends with cousins on facebook, half by choice and half by sheer pressure. Facebook is and should never be a tool for family communication.
(3) Co-workers: if you really want to achieve effective, career-related communication, do not facebook message people, do not friend people just because you want your resume dropped (similarly, do not chat with them on aim). It is just unprofessional, it is invasion of someone’s personal space without their permission. Sure, you are asking to friend him, but he will feel like an asshole for not wanting to friend you and he will be angry at you for making him feel like an asshole.
If you are a coworker I want to be friends with, let’s hang out. If you are a coworker I just want to be coworkers with, it’s best you don’t see my profile on facebook – use LinkedIn instead.
The Bottom Line of what Facebook is Really About:
(1) It’s a Popularity Contest
Some days I feel better when I have 370 friends and 160 photo tags. Some days I feel better when someone writes a witty comment on my wall, especially about how awesome I am. Some days I read someone’s funny status update and feel the need to write something even funnier. Once out of desperation I wrote, “I love NYC, ready to party it up now!!!” How pathetic was that?
Facebook is a popularity contest about what hot parties you went to this weekend and what hot friends you have. It’s about how many people write on your walls and what sarcastically fascinating profiles you can create. But it’s a popularity contest where both the winner and the loser get screwed over. Too many photo tags will make you “seem” popular, but will also make others hate you, prejudging you into a snobby and character-less bitch or son of a bitch. Similarly, when you have less than 50 friends, an empty wall and no tagged photos, you are a loser by default. But really – how can Facebook just label someone a loser without knowing anything about this person? Too bad, it just did.
Isn’t it better to show who you really are in person and on a one-on-one basis instead?
Some people will argue right now that the precise point for facebook to exist is that one-on-one opportunities to showcase yourself is not always possible. This brings me to my last point:
(2) Facebook is used by people who are scared of real communications.
If a guy likes a girl, go ahead and get her number, don’t just facebook her. If calling is too much for him to handle, then he should text. Text, don’t write on her wall “last night’s party was awesome.” It gets him nowhere.
If you meet someone new, same or opposite sex, and find him or her a cool person, then see him or her next week, have coffee, go visit a gallery or hang out at another party. I have met too many new friends with whom I became friends with on facebook and thus, never felt the need to keep in touch outside of the Net.
Wouldn’t it be meaningful if you actually write to me and we actually meet up, either on a weekend or next time you are in town? Wouldn’t it be interesting if, instead of reading my profile, you ask questions yourself and I tailor my answers just for you? Wouldn’t you feel special knowing something about me that is not mass produced and readily available to the public?
I’m not trying to get dates or become best friends. People expect too much from face-to-face communications that they are afraid to commit, and so instead, they facebook and think everything is okay. Well, everything is only okay because there is nothing there.
I wish someone can do a study to show that Facebook event-invites precisely produce lower turnouts because it is too easy to mass-invite. So nobody feels special anymore, and nobody feels the need to turn up because nobody feels like they are genuinely invited.
Conclusion:
Real communications are risky – they involve embarrassing blunders (cute guy does not call me back and it’s been 2 weeks) and huge rewards (10 missed calls from the cute guy). Facebook is riskless – therefore also meaningless. What’s the point of not failing big and winning big, that’s life!